15 min read

Top 4 Plumbers in Indianapolis, IN

Quick Comparison

Firm Founded / Tenure & Credentials Services & Specialties Geographic Focus
Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc. Continuous family operation since 1901 (124 years), one of the oldest continuously operating plumbing practices in Indianapolis; Indiana State License #106214; current generation of owners with 60+ years of plumbing repair and service industry experience; family-owned and operated multigenerational business Residential and commercial plumbing, water heaters (installation, repair), water softeners, whole house plumbing systems, leak detection, sump pumps, frozen pipe repair, slab leak services, home plumbing inspections, master plumbing services, same-day service, after-hours emergency plumbing repair Near Southside HQ (1819 Shelby Street, Indianapolis, IN 46203); Indianapolis and surrounding townships and counties in Central Indiana
Godby Heating Plumbing Electrical Continuous operation since 1971 (54 years), locally and family-owned business with founding-era origin from one truck and a single operating mission; multigenerational customer base across "generations of families" served; expanded service stack from HVAC origin into plumbing and electrical for whole-home service coverage; integrated home-services profile across three regulated trade categories Heating and cooling (HVAC), plumbing (faucet and fixture repairs, toilet repairs and replacements, drain cleaning and clog removal, garbage disposal repairs, pipe leak detection, water pressure diagnostics, sump pump installation and maintenance, water heater service), electrical Northwest Indianapolis HQ (7852 Moller Road, Indianapolis, IN 46268); Indianapolis and surrounding areas including Carmel, Speedway, and broader Indiana communities
Carter's My Plumber Continuous family operation since 1976 (49 years), founded by Bob Carter ("Grandpa Bob") with founding-era trade roots in 1969 plumbing-career origin; three-generation Carter family operation with Bob Carter as founder, Jamie Carter as second-generation operator, and Kelson Carter (Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor) as third-generation operator; Kelson's wife Ali (Occupational Therapist) contributes to daily operations; combined 100+ years of plumbing experience across the three Carter generations; Master Plumber License #CO88900054; 4.9 out of 5 star Google rating with 3,455 customer reviews Residential and commercial plumbing repair and replacement, fixture installation, water heater service, drain cleaning, sewer line work, leak detection, gas line work, transparent up-front pricing North Indianapolis HQ (450 East 96th Street, Suite 500, Indianapolis, IN 46240); Downtown office (55 South State Avenue, Suite 141, Indianapolis, IN 46201); Greenwood office (886 North State Road 135, Suite A, Greenwood, IN 46142); 19+ greater Indianapolis communities
Cooper's Water Continuous family operation since 1980 (45 years); Indiana plumbing license CO#52200024; BBB Accredited; NARI (National Association of the Remodeling Industry) member; technicians described as trained and certified; 2020 Best of HomeAdvisor Winner; 2020 Angie's List Super Service Award Plumbing services, water softening systems, water heater installation and service, water filtration, water quality testing, leak detection, drain services, fixture work Northeast Indianapolis HQ (3131 North Franklin Road, Suite A2, Indianapolis, IN 46226); Greater Indianapolis and Central Indiana including Avon, Brownsburg, Carmel, Fishers, Greenwood, McCordsville, Noblesville, Plainfield, Zionsville

1. Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc.

  • Address: 1819 Shelby Street, Indianapolis, IN 46203
  • Phone: (317) 784-1870 (main); (317) 714-0759 (cell)
  • Operating Since: 1901 (124 years of continuous family operation, among the oldest continuously operating plumbing practices in Indianapolis)
  • Indiana State License: #106214
  • Current Generation Operating Experience: Owners with 60+ years of combined plumbing repair and service industry experience
  • Family Status: Family-owned and operated multigenerational business
  • Service area: Indianapolis and surrounding townships and counties across Central Indiana
  • Website: weilhammerplumbing.com

Sustained Indianapolis Ownership Since the 1901 Founding

Weilhammer Plumbing Co. Inc. has operated continuously since 1901, supporting a 124-year tenure that places the firm among the oldest continuously operating plumbing practices in Indianapolis. The 124-year service span spans the full Indianapolis building stock evolution from the early-twentieth-century downtown commercial-and-residential development through the streetcar-suburb residential expansion across Irvington and Woodruff Place (1900s-1920s), the prewar bungalow-belt construction across the Westside and Southside (1910s-1940s), the postwar suburban tract expansion across Lawrence and Castleton (1950s-1970s), the 1980s-2000s North Side master-planned-community surge across Carmel and Fishers, and the contemporary urban-renovation cycle across Fountain Square, Fletcher Place, and the broader downtown corridor. The Shelby Street headquarters at 1819 Shelby Street places the firm geographically inside the historic Fountain Square corridor on the Near Southside, with the founding-era address tying Weilhammer to the original Indianapolis residential service market.

Indiana State License #106214 Plus Multi-Decade Owner Experience

Weilhammer Plumbing operates under Indiana State License #106214, with the license number positioning the firm’s regulatory-credential foundation across the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency framework. The current generation of owners hold 60+ years of plumbing repair and service industry experience, grounding the operating-team experience profile across multiple decades of Indianapolis service work. The 60-year cumulative owner experience profile combined with the 124-year continuous firm operating tenure generates a credential-and-tenure stack that distinguishes Weilhammer from contemporary newer Indianapolis plumbing competitors. The multigenerational family day-to-day setup preserves the trade-knowledge transfer across owner generations, with the century-spanning trade context for how 1901-era Indianapolis plumbing was specified through the original municipal water-and-sewer infrastructure carrying forward across the recent operating period.

Whole-Home Service Stack Plus Same-Day Operating Profile

The Weilhammer service stack spans residential and commercial plumbing, water heaters (installation and repair), water softeners, whole house plumbing systems, leak detection, sump pumps, frozen pipe repair, slab leak services, home plumbing inspections, and master plumbing services. The same-day plumbing service plus after-hours emergency plumbing repair firm profile distinguishes Weilhammer from appointment-only competitors in the Indianapolis market. The water softener specialty addresses the Indianapolis-specific water-quality profile where Citizens Energy Group source-water blends produce moderate-to-high mineral content across the Indianapolis distribution system, driving substantial residential demand for whole-house softening systems particularly across the older neighborhood building stock. The frozen-pipe-repair specialty addresses the Indianapolis-specific seasonal-failure mode that the Midwest winter climate routinely produces across the older pre-insulation-era residential plumbing.

Near Southside Headquarters Plus Central Indiana Reach

Weilhammer operates from the 1819 Shelby Street headquarters in the Near Southside Fountain Square corridor of Indianapolis, with the headquarters position shaping daily-dispatch reach across Indianapolis and surrounding townships and counties in Central Indiana. The Fountain Square location grounds the firm geographically inside the dense early-twentieth-century residential building stock corridor where 1900s-1940s craftsman bungalows and prewar commercial-residential mixed-use construction defines the typical service profile. Service work on the Fountain Square plus broader Near Southside neighborhoods (Bates-Hendricks, Garfield Park, University Heights, Old Southside) requires the century-spanning trade context for how 1900s-1930s Indianapolis plumbing was specified through the original municipal water service infrastructure that the firm’s 124-year continuous operating tenure has produced across the four-plus generations of Weilhammer family operating leadership.

Master Plumbing Specialty Plus 1819 Shelby Street Founding-Era Location

Weilhammer’s master plumbing specialty extends the firm’s service profile beyond standard residential repair work into the licensed-master-plumber specification work that complex permit-pulling, code-compliance, and new-construction work requires. The Indiana Professional Licensing Agency administers master plumber licensing through individual-license-holder credentials, with Weilhammer’s State License #106214 setting permit-pulling authority across the Indianapolis-and-Central-Indiana service area. The 1819 Shelby Street headquarters has rooted the firm’s Indianapolis operating presence through the present-era period, with the address tying Weilhammer to the historic Fountain Square commercial-and-residential corridor where the firm’s founding-era operating presence began. The combination of the 124-year continuous operating tenure, the master plumber credential, and the founding-era Shelby Street headquarters location produces an operating record that few Indianapolis plumbing operations match.

2. Godby Heating Plumbing Electrical

  • Address: 7852 Moller Road, Indianapolis, IN 46268
  • Phone: (317) 471-8700
  • Operating Since: 1971 (54 years of continuous service)
  • Operating Status: Locally and family-owned
  • Founding-Era Origin: Started with one truck and the single operating mission “treat customers the way we’d want to be treated”
  • Service Categories: Heating, cooling, plumbing, electrical (integrated three-trade home-services profile)
  • Service area: Indianapolis and surrounding areas including Carmel, Speedway, and broader Central Indiana communities
  • Website: godbyhpe.com

Family Operation Since 1971 With Single-Truck Founding-Era Origin

Godby Heating Plumbing Electrical has operated continuously since 1971, with the founding-era origin tracing to one truck and a single operating mission. The 54-year deployment area covers the full Indianapolis-area suburban expansion from the early-1970s pre-housing-boom era through the 1980s-1990s North Side residential development across Carmel and Fishers, the post-2008 maintenance era, and the contemporary Indianapolis-metro residential-and-commercial service market. The Northwest Indianapolis headquarters at 7852 Moller Road places the firm geographically inside the I-465 corridor adjacent to the Carmel and Speedway suburban submarkets, with daily-dispatch reach extending across the broader Indianapolis metropolitan area. The locally and family-owned operating stance places the firm’s Indianapolis identity across the multi-decade tenure window.

Three-Trade Integrated Service Profile Plus Multigenerational Customer Base

Godby’s category breadth spans heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical work, with the integrated three-trade operating capacity supporting whole-home renovation projects through one operating team. The HVAC-to-plumbing-to-electrical service expansion reflects the firm’s category-growth trajectory from the original 1971 HVAC-focused founding through the contemporary integrated home-services profile. The whole-home capability means a single Indianapolis homeowner can route plumbing service plus HVAC replacement plus electrical panel upgrade through one operating team during comprehensive renovation work, removing the typical specification friction between trades. The published operating posture references “generations of families” served across the firm’s tenure, framing multigenerational customer-relationship continuity across the 54-year Indianapolis service history.

Northwest Indianapolis Headquarters Plus Carmel-Speedway Coverage

Godby operates from the 7852 Moller Road Northwest Indianapolis headquarters (ZIP 46268), with the Moller Road position shaping daily-dispatch reach across the Northwest Indianapolis corridor (Pike Township, Speedway, Eagle Creek, Westside) plus the North Side master-planned-community submarkets (Carmel, Zionsville, Westfield, Fishers). The Northwest Indianapolis location places Godby inside the dense 1980s-2000s suburban tract development corridor where the Indianapolis metro suburban expansion has concentrated most heavily. The plumbing service scope covers faucet and fixture repairs, toilet repairs and replacements, drain cleaning and clog removal, garbage disposal repairs, pipe leak detection, water pressure diagnostics, sump pump installation and maintenance, and water heater service. The integrated three-trade working framework supports both scheduled-service and emergency-response work across the broader Indianapolis-metro service area.

3. Carter’s My Plumber

  • Address (North Indianapolis HQ): 450 East 96th Street, Suite 500, Indianapolis, IN 46240
  • Address (Downtown): 55 South State Avenue, Suite 141, Indianapolis, IN 46201
  • Address (Greenwood): 886 North State Road 135, Suite A, Greenwood, IN 46142
  • Phone: (317) 859-9999; (317) 893-2462; (317) 893-2485
  • Hours: Monday through Saturday, 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM (closed Sunday); 24/7 scheduling available
  • Founder: Bob Carter (“Grandpa Bob”)
  • Generational Succession: Bob Carter (first generation, founder) → Jamie Carter (second generation, son, joined during high school and focused on the service sector) → Kelson Carter (third generation, grandson, Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor); Kelson’s wife Ali (Occupational Therapist) contributes to daily operations
  • Operating Since: 1976 (49 years of continuous family operation; founder Bob Carter’s plumbing-career origin reaches back to 1969 producing 56-year cumulative founder plumbing tenure)
  • Combined Family Experience: Over 100 years of plumbing experience across the three Carter generations
  • License: Master Plumber License #CO88900054
  • Credentials: 4.9 out of 5 star Google rating with 3,455 customer reviews
  • Service area: 19+ greater Indianapolis region communities
  • Website: cartersmyplumber.com

Three-Generation Carter Family Succession From Bob Carter Founding

Carter’s My Plumber has operated continuously since 1976 under the Carter family, with founder Bob Carter’s plumbing-career origin tracing to 1969 (a 56-year cumulative founder plumbing tenure that pre-dates the firm’s 1976 establishment). The three-generation Carter family operating succession runs across Bob Carter as founder, Jamie Carter as second-generation operator (joined during high school, later focused on the service sector), and Kelson Carter as third-generation operator (Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor). Kelson’s wife Ali (Occupational Therapist by profession) contributes to daily operations, rooting the family-operating-team profile across today’s period. The combined 100+ years of plumbing experience across the three Carter generations distinguishes Carter’s My Plumber within the Indianapolis residential service market, with the deep family-trade tenure producing institutional knowledge across decades of Indianapolis building stock evolution.

Master Plumber License #CO88900054 Plus Three-Office Indianapolis Footprint

Carter’s My Plumber operates under Master Plumber License #CO88900054, with Kelson Carter holding the Licensed Master Plumber and Licensed Plumbing Contractor credentials supporting permit-pulling authority across the Indianapolis-area dispatch reach. The three-office operating arrangement covers North Indianapolis (450 East 96th Street, Suite 500, in the Keystone-and-North-Meridian corridor), Downtown Indianapolis (55 South State Avenue, Suite 141, near Fountain Square), and Greenwood (886 North State Road 135, Suite A, in the southern suburban Johnson County corridor). The three-office footprint distinguishes Carter’s from single-office Indianapolis plumbing competitors, with the daily-dispatch reach extending across the central, north, and south corridors of the Indianapolis metro area. The 4.9 out of 5 star Google rating with 3,455 customer reviews grounds the modern online customer-feedback profile.

Nineteen-Plus Community Greater Indianapolis Service Area

Carter’s My Plumber operates a 19+ named-community greater Indianapolis service area covering Indianapolis, Greenwood, Whiteland, Franklin, Bargersville, Trafalgar, Mooresville, Wanamaker, Beech Grove, Southport, Plainfield, Perry Township, Homecroft, Avon, Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Meridian-Kessler, and Zionsville. The 19-community footprint covers the southern-suburban Johnson County corridor (Greenwood, Whiteland, Franklin, Bargersville, Trafalgar) plus the central Indianapolis neighborhoods (Beech Grove, Southport, Wanamaker, Perry Township, Homecroft, Meridian-Kessler) plus the western-and-northern suburban corridors (Plainfield, Avon, Mooresville, Fishers, Carmel, Noblesville, Zionsville). The breadth supports both inner-Indianapolis renovation work and the outer-suburban tract-home service market through one operating dispatch model. The Monday-through-Saturday 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM operating hours plus 24/7 scheduling availability extends coverage beyond typical weekday-only Indianapolis plumbing service windows.

4. Cooper’s Water

  • Address: 3131 North Franklin Road, Suite A2, Indianapolis, IN 46226
  • Phone: (317) 268-8890
  • Operating Since: 1980 (45 years of continuous family operation)
  • Operating Status: Family-owned business
  • Indiana License: CO#52200024
  • Credentials: BBB Accredited; NARI (National Association of the Remodeling Industry) member; technicians trained and certified; 2020 Best of HomeAdvisor Winner; 2020 Angie’s List Super Service Award
  • Service area: Greater Indianapolis and Central Indiana
  • Website: cooperswater.com

Family Operation Since 1980 With Water-Quality Specialty

Cooper’s Water has operated continuously since 1980 as a family-owned business serving the Greater Indianapolis and Central Indiana area. The 45-year deployment area covers the post-1980 Indianapolis suburban expansion, the 1990s-2000s North Side master-planned-community surge across Carmel and Fishers, the post-2008 maintenance cycle, and the contemporary residential and commercial service market. The firm’s published service profile emphasizes water softening services alongside conventional plumbing service work, grounding a water-quality specialty positioning within the broader Indianapolis plumbing market. The water-quality specialty addresses the Indianapolis-specific water-mineralization profile that Citizens Energy Group source-water blends produce across the regional distribution system, driving substantial residential demand for whole-house softening, water filtration, and reverse-osmosis system installation work.

Indiana License CO#52200024 Plus NARI Membership Recognition

Cooper’s Water operates under Indiana License #CO52200024, with the license number establishing the firm’s regulatory-credential foundation. Beyond the underlying state license, Cooper’s holds BBB Accredited Business status plus NARI (National Association of the Remodeling Industry) membership. The NARI membership distinguishes Cooper’s from typical residential-service-only plumbing competitors, with the remodeling-industry trade association affiliation underpinning the firm’s positioning in the kitchen-and-bathroom remodeling segment that overlaps plumbing into the contractor-scope renovation work. The 2020 Best of HomeAdvisor Winner award plus the 2020 Angie’s List Super Service Award ground the firm’s contemporary recognition profile across the major online review platforms.

Northeast Indianapolis Headquarters Plus Nine-Community Service Footprint

Cooper’s Water operates from 3131 North Franklin Road in Northeast Indianapolis (ZIP 46226), with the Franklin Road position shaping daily-dispatch reach across nine named greater Indianapolis communities: Avon (western suburb), Brownsburg (western suburb), Carmel (North Side master-planned community), Fishers (North Side suburb), Greenwood (south suburb), McCordsville (Northeast suburb), Noblesville (North-Northeast suburb), Plainfield (western suburb), and Zionsville (Northwest suburb). The nine-community footprint distinguishes Cooper’s from neighborhood-grounded Indianapolis plumbers, with the breadth supporting both North Side luxury renovation work and Westside-and-Southside tract-home service work through one operating dispatch model. The Northeast Indianapolis location roots the operating base inside the broader I-465 ring-road corridor, with daily dispatch routing efficiently across the Indianapolis metro area’s major north-south and east-west arteries.

Reference Notes

Indianapolis plumbing licensing runs through the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency (IPLA) and the Indiana State Plumbing Commission (master plumber credentials carry sequentially numbered IPLA license IDs verifiable through the agency’s public lookup. Within Indianapolis-Marion County, the City of Indianapolis Department of Business and Neighborhood Services issues building permits, and Citizens Energy Group handles water-and-sewer service connections plus backflow-certification compliance. Outside the city-county, suburban municipalities (Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, Greenwood, Plainfield, Avon, Brownsburg, Zionsville, McCordsville) administer their own permit frameworks across surrounding Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson, Madison, Morgan, and Shelby Counties.

Indianapolis residential housing spans about 150 years of construction. Pre-1910 streetcar-suburb housing dominates Lockerbie Square, Old Northside, Herron-Morton Place, and Woodruff Place. Craftsman-bungalow stock from 1900-1930 fills Irvington, Garfield Park, Fountain Square, and the Near Southside. Post-war tract housing built out Lawrence, Castleton, Speedway, and the I-465 ring-road corridor. Carmel, Fishers, and Zionsville drove the 1980s-1990s North Side master-planned boom. Westfield and Noblesville extended the surge through the 2000s. The Midwest expansive-soil substrate plus the regional hard-water profile shape recurring service categories: cast-iron drain replacement in pre-1930 stock, slab-foundation plumbing in postwar tract homes, water-softener service across the metro, and frozen-pipe repair through the long winter.

The four firms profiled cover four positions on the Indianapolis market arc. Weilhammer Plumbing carries the longest tenure (1901 founding, 124 years, current owners with 60+ years field experience). Master plumbing plus water-softener-and-frozen-pipe specialties match the local climate and water profile. Carter’s My Plumber holds the deepest contemporary three-generation succession story: Bob Carter (founder, 1969 trade entry), Jamie Carter (second generation), and Kelson Carter (current Licensed Master Plumber, License #CO88900054). Carter’s three-office footprint covers North Indianapolis, Downtown, and Greenwood with a 4.9-star Google rating across 3,455 reviews. Godby Heating Plumbing Electrical (1971) brings the broadest service stack through integrated HVAC, plumbing, and electrical from a Northwest Indianapolis I-465 base. Cooper’s Water (1980, IPLA #CO52200024, NARI member, 2020 HomeAdvisor and Angie’s List awards) supports water-quality plus remodeling-industry specialization across nine named communities.

Verification paths run through the IPLA public lookup, the City of Indianapolis Department of Business and Neighborhood Services records, BBB Indianapolis listings, the PHCC of Indiana directory, and the NARI member directory. Pre-1930 housing tilts toward Weilhammer’s master plumbing specialty. Renovation projects fit Cooper’s NARI-credentialed scope. Suburban whole-home work fits Godby’s three-trade stack. Multi-property scheduling fits Carter’s three-office footprint.

Selection Methodology

Selection follows four criteria. First, continuous family ownership or founder-operator continuity outside the national rollup pattern. Second, verifiable IN Master Plumber license cross-checked via the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency (IPLA) Plumbing Commission public lookup. Third, BBB Accreditation or equivalent third-party rating. Fourth, minimum 10-year continuous operating tenure with documented Indianapolis, IN service coverage. Firms acquired by national franchise networks (Authority Brands’ Benjamin Franklin Plumbing, Neighborly’s Mr. Rooter, Service Experts, Roto-Rooter, Wrench Group, Redwood Services, Master Trades Group, ARS) are excluded.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I verify a Indianapolis, IN plumber’s license?

Use the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency (IPLA) Plumbing Commission public licensee database at in.gov/pla. Search by license number or business name. Confirm active status, classification, bonding, and insurance before authorizing work.

What credentials should a Indianapolis, IN plumber hold?

At minimum: IN Master Plumber credential plus general liability insurance and workers’ compensation coverage. Specialty work (gas line, backflow prevention, fire sprinkler, sewer lateral) requires additional credential layers.

How can I tell if a Indianapolis, IN plumber is locally owned versus a national rollup?

Check ownership disclosures and acquisition history. National franchise brands typically operate under parent-company branding. Search the firm name plus “acquired” or “parent company” to surface ownership structure. The four firms in this directory all run as independent locally-owned operators.

When should I call an emergency plumber in Indianapolis?

Burst pipes, sewer backups, gas leaks, no-water events, and water heater failures justify after-hours dispatch. Each firm in this directory offers either 24/7 emergency service or structured after-hours response.

Editorial Note

Compiled by the editorial team. Firm details cross-verified through state license databases, BBB business profiles, and firm-published websites where available. License numbers should be re-verified through the Indiana Professional Licensing Agency (IPLA) Plumbing Commission public lookup before authorizing work. Information current as of the date below; firm details may change without notice. Last updated: 2026-05-10.